clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

The College Football Playoff Rankings Flakes

New, 121 comments

Let the playoff hunt begin!

If you buy something from an SB Nation link, Vox Media may earn a commission. See our ethics statement.

COLLEGE FOOTBALL: OCT 08 Temple at Cincinnati Photo by Ian Johnson/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images

The first poll from the college football selection committee came in yesterday and here’s the rankings:

1. Georgia 8-0

2. Alabama 7-1

3. Michigan State 8-0

4. Oregon 7-1

5. Ohio State 7-1

6. Cincinnati 8-0

7. Michigan 7-1

8. Oklahoma 9-0

9. Wake Forest 8-0

10. Notre Dame 7-1

11. Oklahoma State 7-1

12. Baylor 7-1

13. Auburn 6-2

14. Texas A&M 6-2

15. BYU 7-2

16. Mississippi 6-2

17. Mississippi State 5-3

18. Kentucky 6-2

19. NC State 6-2

20. Minnesota 6-2

21. Wisconsin 5-3

22. Iowa 6-2

23. Fresno State 7-2

24. San Diego State 7-1

25. Pittsburgh 6-2

Is it what most of us expected? For the most part, yes. Minnesota making it was a bit of a surprise. As with Mississippi State to a certain extent. UTSA not in was a bit of a let down. The Road Runners are having a heck of a season and I expected to see them in at least at the bottom.

Cincinnati ranked #6? Do they belong in the top 4? Maybe they do. They did beat Notre Dame. But, I doubt the powers that be want a G5 school in the playoffs and have that money not go to a P5 conference.

Is this pure speculation on my part? Of course it is. No one would ever admit to it. Well, maybe down the road in a biography but that’s not going to change anything.

Is this a good list? Sure, why not? College football, at least big time FBS college football has never made sense. Why would we expect a group of 13 people in a room to make decisions that would bring happiness to everyone?

Honestly, if you want to watch college football in a fairly just and fair system then watch the lower leagues. FCS, Division III, Division III/NAIA have playoff structures that seem to work seamlessly. It’s also good football for the most part. Will you be watching NFL level talent? No, most likely not. Baggers can’t be choosers.

Why doesn’t the FBS move to a model like the lower division? That’s a great question and I probably could not answer it in one article. You have big schools and conferences that do not want to share the wealth. You have bowls and cities that house the bowls that rely on the employment and income of these bowl games. Traditions and conference tie ins that will never die. Fanbases that want to go to said bowls. You also have small schools with no power whatsoever in what is going on. The list goes on and on.

So, sit back and enjoy what has come out and wait and see what will come next week. Maybe just maybe there will be some upsets in the top 25 and a new school will come up and replace the loser.

Mankilling Mastodons

Nebraska Basketball: Husker commit Ramel Lloyd Jr. further sold on official visit
2022 guard Ramel Lloyd Jr. was already sold on Nebraska, but his second official visit further confirmed his commitment.

Nebraska Shoots Lights Out, Takes Exhibition Over Buffs - University of Colorado Athletics
Colorado men's basketball looked forward to its exhibition against Nebraska to gauge where the young Buffaloes were at this point of the preseason and what needed

Coach Scott Frost, trying to 'control what we can control,' admits Nebraska Cornhuskers have fallen shy of expectations
Facing mounting pressure with Nebraska on the cusp of a fifth straight losing season, coach Scott Frost acknowledged this year has fallen far short of his expectations on Monday as the Cornhuskers began preparations for Ohio State.

HuskerOnline - Three & Out: New offers, Husker fans impress, and 2023 QB intrigue
Three & Out: New offers, Husker fans impress, and 2023 QB intrigue.

Other News From The Sporting World

World Series score: Braves win first title in 26 years after slugging past Astros in Game 6 - CBSSports.com
Jorge Soler, Dansby Swanson and Freddie Freeman all homered in the clinching victory on Tuesday night

Henry Ruggs III fatal crash in Las Vegas: What we know
Ex-Raiders WR Henry Ruggs III was charged after being involved in a fatal two-car accident early Tuesday morning. Here is the latest on his situation.

Georgia tops first CFP rankings release, followed by Alabama, Michigan State and Oregon
Coach Kirby Smart and the Georgia Bulldogs, fresh off their win over the Florida Gators on Saturday, are No. 1 in the first release of the College Football Playoff rankings, announced on ESPN Tuesday night, followed by Alabama, Michigan State and Oregon.

Sources: Conference USA 'Likely' to Add Liberty, New Mexico State, 2 FCS Schools in Realignment Move
Read about Conference USA's plan to add Liberty, New Mexico State, Sam Houston, and Jacksonville State.

Colt Brennan, Hawaii's Heisman nominee, went to "the dark side" - Sports Illustrated
For those close to him, his football afterlife was an excruciating cycle of addiction. In his last days, he seemed to see the bigger picture.

Reports: Former USC coach Clay Helton headed to Georgia Southern
Clay Helton was fired at USC earlier this year after leading the Trojans to a Rose Bowl victory in 2016 and a Pac-12 title in 2017. He went 46-24.

Aztecs football players become brand ambassadors for College HUNKS Hauling Junk - The San Diego Union-Tribune
NIL deal with moving company spreads $20,000 among players who promote its brand on social media

Inside the room where College Football Playoff teams are chosen: 13 things they don't tell you about the committee – The Athletic
Why are there 13 College Football Playoff committee members? How do they pick their top 25 and get down to four teams? And more.

Sources: MAC 'Likely' to Add Western Kentucky, Middle Tennessee In College Football Conference Realignment Move
Read about how Western Kentucky and Middle Tennessee are likely to join the MAC in the latest college football conference realignment move.

Big Ten Coaching Hot Seats Week 10 - Scott Frost Stats Sheridan O’Neil - Off Tackle Empire Passing the hat around for Scott Frost extension donations

NCAA grants many college football teams Election Day waivers - Sports Illustrated
Legislation passed last year is supposed to give college athletes Election Day off, but that isn't the case for many in 2021.

Yellow Journalism

If Less Vaping Means More Smoking, That Won't Be a Public Health Victory - Reason.com
Cigarette sales rose last year for the first time in two decades, while a survey of high school seniors found they were vaping less but smoking more.

Disneyland in Shanghai is shut down and 30,000 are tested, over one COVID case : NPR
On Sunday, people weren't allowed to leave the park due to contact tracing after a woman tested positive for COVID-19 after her visit. It's the latest in China's strict measures to fight the disease.

The American Scholar: Why We Need the Humanities - <a href='https://theamericanscholar.org/author/james-a-w-heffernan/'>James A. W. Heffernan</a>
A little over five years ago, a pair of huge, exquisitely crafted L-shaped antennas in Louisiana and Washington State picked up the chirping echo of two black holes colliding in space a billion years ago—and a billion light years away.

What we’re doing when we’re doing epistemology | Aeon Essays
Correct information doesn’t always come with its own bright halo of truth. What makes something worth believing?

How Does Salt Work and Why Does It Make Food Taste So Good? | Bon Appétit
How does salt work to make sweet food sweeter, savory food more savory, and crunchy foods even crunchier? Learn how to properly use this MVP ingredient.

Auditory Enlightenment