clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Friday Flakes: To Redshirt or Not to Redshirt a Freshman

New, 100 comments

...that is the question.

Nebraska Spring Game Photo by Steven Branscombe/Getty Images

The relatively new four-year redshirt rule is fun. It opens up entirely knew possibilities for people to go back and forth on whether freshmen should or should not play in particular games.

Example one of that conundrum is the case of Ty Robinson. The true freshman out of Arizona is listed as 6’6” 315 pounds. From all indications it sounds like he is making quite the impression in fall camp.

It could be all smoke. Frost, Chinander and Tuioti may want us chasing our tails so we hear comments from both players and coaches about Robinson. They could be evil scientists.

This one of many clips of one rep from one drill that many members of the media shared on social media of Ty Robinson shaking off Ethan Piper.

Ty Robinson looks the part already as a true freshman.

So there is a two part question. Does the staff have the intention to redshirt Ty Robinson? If they do, but still want to use him in the maximum four games, are they picky about which games to use him?

Get him experience against South Alabama or get real experience against Wisconsin and Iowa?

See? This is fun.

If it weren’t for the immediate infusion of talent from Darrion Daniels and Jahkeem Green then I believe the answer would be simple. He needs to play right away. Now with Daniels and Green on the roster there is an opportunity to save this year for Ty Robinson to be used in the future when there isn’t so much depth.

Unfortunately, it is probably true to say that this upcoming season is an exception to the rule for Nebraska defensive lines. This year the defensive line is an obvious strength with tremendous depth.

Take the last ten or so years. Are there any seasons where Ty Robinson likely would not have come in and burned his redshirt in his true freshman season? Isn’t it likely he would have played right away? Maybe not started but played more than four games.

Hopefully injuries don’t force the coaches hand, because until then we can talk about whether he should play against South Alabama.

Then there’s the case of Wandale.

And Luke McCaffrey.

And Bryce Benhart.

And...


This Week From Corn Nation

Purdue Boilermakers 2019 Football Preview

2019 Nebraska Football Position Breakdown: Outside Linebackers, Domann, Davis, Ferguson, Tannor, Nelson

Nebrasketball: Washington State Preseason Preview

Nebraska Cornhuskers Football #24 in Preseason SBNation NCAA FanPulse Poll

Nebraska Football Practice Report August 14 Adrian Martinez and the Offense

Nebraska #2 in Pre-season Volleyball Coaches Poll

Of Bangarangs & Daggers Episode 14: The Hot Sauce Episode Rome Italy Doc Sadler Nebraska Basketball

Nebraska Football Practice Report August 13: Defensive Update Erik Chinander

2019 Nebraska Football Position Breakdown: Wide Receivers

Nebraska’s JD Spielman: The Little Big Man From Paul Bunyan’s Hood

Overview of an Exciting Cornhusker Volleyball Schedule

Jon’s Post-life Crisis: Nebraska vs Purdue - Culture Clash

Read All About It! Sports! Sports!

FIBA World Cup: Team USA loses scrimmage to G League players
It’s still probably not time to panic for Team USA ahead of the FIBA World Cup in China, but the team is not exactly inspiring confidence right now.

McCaffrey stays humble as he attacks QB competition
Those on the outside may call them "a football family," but Luke McCaffrey doesn't think of it in those terms even if those backyard games were pretty dang intense. Seriously, can you imagine those things?

Huskers Running Back Ronald Thompkins Returns to the Football Field | Hail Varsity
When the Nebraska running backs gathered for a team meeting on Monday, a new face was among them. Ronald Thompkins, the 4-star running back from Grayson High School in Loganville, Georgia, had joined the fold after not starting the fall on the 110-man roster.

A Sense of Urgency from the Huskers' Wide Receivers | Hail Varsity
Cam Taylor is playing corner, safety and even a little Cinco linebacker on defense. Meaning in coverage he’s handling all types of receivers. Who stands out amongst the young guys in offensive coordinator/wideout coach Troy Walters’ room? “I’ll give you Darien Chase,” the sophomore said.

Southland DE Tuli Tuipulotu working towards a top list
Lawndale (Calif.) defensive end Tuli Tuipulotu is hoping to name a top schools list soon.

For now, Tuipulotu has seven schools standing out to him.

Earnhardt Jr., wife OK after Tenn. plane crash
Dale Earnhardt Jr. will take the weekend off from broadcasting to be with his wife and daughter after the three were in a plane crash-landing Thursday near Bristol Motor Speedway.

The Legendary Workout Stories of Frank Gore, Football’s Indestructible Force - The Ringer
As the 36-year-old RB prepares for his 15th NFL season, he’s had to search for younger players to train with in the offseason. Gone are the days of summer workouts with Fred Taylor and Maurice Jones-Drew. Now it’s Dalvin Cook, James Conner, and … Frank Gore Jr.

Vedral sees depth building at Nebraska
Unlike everyone else on Nebraska’s roster, quarterback Noah Vedral is going into his third season with the staff and he knows what the team looked like at UCF when everything clicked.

Will Farniok added the weight ... and the command
Will Farniok expected the scale to one day read such a number back to him, but admittedly it is still new enough that he's unsure it's telling the truth each day.

The fast feet and the genes to play offensive line at a high level were always there, but for a Farniok boy, he didn't become as big as fast as his brothers.

“STICK TO SPORTS!” Nah.

Fish Tube Meme | How the Salmon Cannon Works
If you’re like us, you were probably enthralled by a hypnotic video that emerged from the depths of the Internet to take charge of Twitter and capture the hearts of millions over the weekend. Just why did these fish flying through tubes resonate so soundly? Better to not look a gift fish in the mouth.

Sarasota sheriff warns parents about 15 apps that could be used to target children - Story | WAGA
The Sarasota County Sheriff's Office made headlines last year when it released a list of apps that could put children at risk of being targeted by predators. Now the sheriff's office has added more apps parents should watch out for on their kids' phones.

The Best Things I Saw On The Internet This Week