Dirk Chatelain Apologizes for Cheap Shots at Taylor Martinez
Just as the furor over Dirk Chatelain's "last chance" ultimatum to Taylor Martinez started to die down, the Omaha World-Herald reporter reopened debate with a partial apology for his article.
Some of my words were too personal for a college athlete. Too harsh for a 21-year old.
For example, in last Friday's column, I referenced Martinez "pouting" during a press conference. I suggested that he "stop with the 'Woe is me.'" I wrote that negativity in the fan base threatens to "sap his confidence."
For those comments and others like them, I apologize to Martinez.
Make it clear, Chatelain isn't apologizing for his conclusion that Martinez should be at the end of his leash. In that light, I frankly don't think this is much of an apology. A lot of people have called Bo Pelini "petulant" over his post-game press conference where he responded to Chatelain's repeated inquiries about Martinez. Frankly, I think Chatelain's "apology" is much more petulant. Certainly, the act of writing and editing gave the World-Herald and it's reporter plenty of time to massage and consider what they were writing. And this was what they chose to run?
This has all the makings of someone who's writing an apology because he's being forced to, not because he wants to. He's limited his apology to the meanest parts of the article. No apology for the conflicting logic of correctly realizing that Nebraska doesn't have any other quarterbacks who can challenge Martinez for playing time, then turning around and calling for those inferior, inexperienced quarterbacks to become the starter.Steve Sipple of the Lincoln Journal-Star summed it up best on Monday:
By suggesting last week that Martinez should be one subpar outing from being benched, the quarterback's critics essentially backed Pelini into a corner -- the clear implication being that if Martinez fails, so does the head coach.
It seemed an extreme stance one game into the Big Ten schedule. It's an extreme stance, period, to place such dire consequences on a young player. One more chance, kid, you'd better not blow it, or else.
What are the consequences for those who casually put Martinez under the gun in that manner? That's right, there are no consequences.
In my opinion, it becomes an issue of fairness.
Chatelain didn't walk that back. He issued an apology because he had to, and found something minor that meant he didn't have to admit that his entire column was a mistake. I was reminded of Jim Tressel's early comments after Tattoo-gate came out; he was only going to admit to what he was forced to admit. It wasn't sincere. And frankly, Chatelain's apology smells the same.
This situation really should drop. I don't know what the purpose of this apology is. People who supported Dirk haven't changed their minds; Dirk hasn't changed his tune about Pelini and Martinez. All it has done is reopen a can of worms that was already starting to fade into the past. It actually makes things worse, because now we're talking about this whole ridiculous column once again. And some people are actually complimenting Dirk for being the "bigger man"?
This was a young reporter who got called out for going overboard. And like a kid, someone in authority told him he needed to apologize. So he apologized.
Just not what he needed to apologize for.
30 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
I'm not
T Mart’s #1 fan…he’s pissed me off plenty of times. But he played hurt most of last year…two other scholarship QBs are no longer here…etc. But when push comes to shove if some young inexperienced QB is thrown into the fire instead of Martinez, Bo would be pilloried for that too. Writers gonna write.
Kids, you tried your best and you failed miserably. The lesson is, never try.
opening fresh wounds
you said this whole ordeal was starting subside until Dirk had to write this apology and making it worse by bringing it back up… you are doing the same thing by writing this article about Dirk writing the apology. Don’t get me wrong, I think Dirk is the one that hurt the program by trying to rip out the morale in our team not Bo for sticking up for the players. He has to protect his assets and it’s sad that the media has to find the bad or whine about their own thoughts instead of encouraging the YOUNG players… they are not professionals… they are YOUNG. Martinez has 2 1/2 years left… plenty of time to develop into a great QB. Yes, we are Nebraska. Yes we were great. Callahan era wiped that dynasty out and Bo has to rebuild. ROME WASN’T BUILT IN A DAY, PEOPLE. give it time.
You are correct that I'm guilty of bringing this up again...
…but the weak apology demanded a response. But yeah, it also needs to die.
Call me conflicted…
by Husker Mike on Oct 13, 2011 7:15 PM CDT via mobile up reply actions
Mike,
I, for one, am happy you wrote this piece. You were one of the few journalists (yes, I consider you a journalist) to call Chatelain out on this.
Thank you.
They're 18 to 22...how perfect were you at that age?
The Power of Red begins with the Passion of Walk-Ons.
AD flexes his muscle
this has all the markings of the athletic department coming down on the OWH. I’m thinking the concept of “limited to no access” was discussed. Wouldn’t be the first time they’ve done this and, in this 24/7 news cycle world, won’t be the last.
Chain Of Command
It goes like this: the Athletic Dept. rips the OWH a new a-hole, then the OWH rips Chatlain a new a-hole. Chain of command; shit rolls down hill.
That being said, apology accepted, Capt. Needa.
Paddle faster, I hear banjos!!
by Section 37 on Oct 13, 2011 2:04 PM CDT up reply actions 1 recs
The Dead Horse Review
College Football Realignment
Angry Bo
Bo vs the World
TM as our QB?
Anything to do with American Politics
Using the expression “beating a dead horse” when something becomes repetitive
SEC is the best eva!
SEC...great conference or the greatest conference?
Whatever
Why should he apologize for his belief that Martinez should be pulled if he kept making mistakes? It’s his opinion, he shouldn’t have to apologize for that. When has Bo ever apologized for anything? This is the same coach who embarassed the program ranting at Martinez last year on national TV @ A & M. Did he ever apologize for that? Agree or disagree with his article, he had the right to write it, and Bo had the right to disagree with it. It’s how Bo handled it that I have a problem with. If his precious Taylor can’t deal with criticism, then hang up your cleats, T-Baby!
If you can't deal with Bo's embarrassment of the program
Then drop your fanhood and stop watching.
Oh wait, not an option? Yeah I thought so too.
One last time, Dirk is an idiot, Taylor is just a kid in college not earning millions, Bo defended his player. Don’t like it? Stop watching.
by Fake Pelini on Oct 13, 2011 2:25 PM CDT via mobile up reply actions 1 recs
Really? Justy stop watching?
How bout if you dont like what a reporter says you stop reading his material?
Just becuase TM isnt making millions we cant criticize his actions? Did some tell Bo that TM wasnt making millions when he yelled at him on the side line last year?
I am sick of this “true fans dont criticize” BS that every one is peddeling.
So I tried the Barbasol and Rotel dip and I was very dissapointed!
It's not that "true fans" don't criticize...
The issue is whether the criticism is constructive or destructive… is it objective or personal. I think saying publicly that if a STUDENT athlete doesn’t like the personal attacks he should quit is what’s BS in this situation.
Let’s put this in perspective… you say you’re sick of this “true fans don’t criticize” because a few fans on a fan board don’t agree with you. Now imagine you’re 20 years old again and half of a state that lives and breathes college football is questioning your effort… I’d think you’d be sick of that BS! How would you feel if you were told that if you think its BS for fans to peddle this "true fans don’t criticize" you should just “hang up your cleats, A-Baby!”.
By the way… I’m not saying that at all. What I am saying is that I’m all for the spirited dialogue that takes place here but I’m going to continue to try to see things from the coaches and players perspective and try lift them up when I can… not tear them down.
The bottom line is that I’m old enough now that when I read something said about one of our players I ask myself if I’d like that said that way to one of my own kids (my screen name kind of says it all). That doesn’t mean I don’t question my kids’ decisions and/or actions but I’ve learned there is a right way and a wrong way to do it. Just my opinion.
Oh and by the way… I agree that the way Coach Pelini handled the situation last year was inappropriate and have no problem saying so.
You missed the point.
My post was in response to “If his precious Taylor can’t deal with criticism, then hang up your cleats.” That’s not an option.
So my post was supposed to make that point, asking for such action is just simply not an option.
Here’s the thing Amonra, Taylor’s performance doesn’t affect your life, mine, or Dirk’s. If I don’t like what Dirk has to say that’s fine, and I won’t read it, the thing is it isn’t about me. What Dirk writes can affect players’ morales.
That’s the difference. That and Taylor is the college kid taking the hits by B1G defenders for no cash while fans and media sit infront of TVs calling for his head because he isn’t Tom Brady’s and Michael Vick’s baby.
by Fake Pelini on Oct 13, 2011 11:46 PM CDT via mobile up reply actions 1 recs
Yes... Chatelain had the right but...
that doesn’t make it right. If you read the article Chatelain was not apologizing for his opinion, he was apologizing for some of the personal things he said about a 20 year old kid.
I would compare this to you having the right to come on this board and say that a 20 year old student athlete who has made mistakes but is playing his heart out for our program deserves to take the level of criticism that has been directed at him from the media and “fans” and that if he doesn’t like it he should quit.
I personally don’t think that’s right and I have the right to state that in my opinion Taylor Martinez is a heck of a lot better quarterback and Bo Pelini a coach than you are a “fan” of my team.
Sure Seemed Contrived To Me
First thought: “Please, plllleeeeeeaaaasssse let me keep my media pass!!”
Second thought: Paul Reubens (Pee Wee Herman) ‘Hamburger dude’ from ‘Nice Dreams’: “I’m sorry…I’m sorry…..I’m SO sorry………….I’m NOT SORRY!! HA”
"Were there monkeys? Some terrifying space monkeys maybe got loose?"
by UltimaRatioRegum on Oct 13, 2011 5:28 PM CDT reply actions
Not sure what the broken link thingy is there.......
"Were there monkeys? Some terrifying space monkeys maybe got loose?"
by UltimaRatioRegum on Oct 13, 2011 5:29 PM CDT up reply actions
Everyone has their rights.
Dirk had the right to write his article. Bo had the right to defend his player. Last year Bo had the right to “coach up” Martinez on the sideline. It is all a bunch of over-reacting if you ask me. Do I like what Dirk wrote? Heck no. But the world is full of people doing things I don’t like. This is a blog and we all have the right to state our opinions on here. Thats what makes our country wonderful and hated all at the same time.
pathetic
Dirk’s column summarized a weeks worth of forum, blog and talk-radio opinion from a loud portion of Husker fans- of which I was not one. But for Bo to lay that all on Dirk is ridiculous, and his continued silence shows me how weak his character is. The hysterical indignation in your blog post belongs at a tea party rally.
by youarenotajournalist on Oct 13, 2011 9:41 PM CDT reply actions
Page reads for OWH.
Nothing more.
A Cornhusker through feast or famine. Get up, dust yourself off and run the ball. That's the Nebraska way.
by Salt Creek and Stadium on Oct 13, 2011 10:27 PM CDT up reply actions
Bingo
And sites like this are no different. Thin-skinned readers…proceed with caution.
Bye weeks = Worst thing ever invented.
by Mitch Taylor on Oct 14, 2011 9:16 AM CDT up reply actions
I was going to let this go but...
Lets see… someone who stands up in front of a national audience and does what he thinks is right by calling out a journalist and defending his player (whether you agree with him or not)… versus someone who anonymously passes judgement on this man’s character and then, out of left field, attacks a political ideology using terminology of an irrational hater who would like to take away the rights of U.S. citizens that he doesn’t agree with to peaceably assemble.
Hmmm… I’ll let everyone else decide who’s character is in question… I’ve made my decision.
So on a totally unrelated subject
To help this die,what do people prefer? Texas Beef BBQ,or SEC Pork BBQ? just curious
Allergic to pork.
Brisket for the win.
A Cornhusker through feast or famine. Get up, dust yourself off and run the ball. That's the Nebraska way.
by Salt Creek and Stadium on Oct 13, 2011 10:27 PM CDT up reply actions
Allergic to pork?
You poor bastard. We need to do a telethon to cure that RIGHT NOW!
So I tried the Barbasol and Rotel dip and I was very dissapointed!
Beef Ain't BBQ
It’s smoked meat.
Only pork is BBQ, and it is King.
"Were there monkeys? Some terrifying space monkeys maybe got loose?"
by UltimaRatioRegum on Oct 13, 2011 10:32 PM CDT up reply actions
WH Gate
The last I heard, OMaha was really not connected to Nebrasks and as such, their local newspaper reporters should be covering their local college team …. the “Mavericks” I believe they are called. Interesting that the WH reporter is such a maverick….it is a fit made in heaven.
Lincoln does not need you Chatelain so go cover the horse races at AKSARBEN…
There are times for tact and diplomacy and times when they should be tossed out the window. Remember the media, which seems to be mostly anyone with a camera, can tape whatever they are able to capture. When it is questionable or seriously out of line, it makes headlines.
Making headlines means more subscribers or viewers and more viewers means more money. How many of us have seen the video of Bo poking Martinez in the chest more than 10 times in the last year? This archived footage is usually used whenever ESPN, ABC, NBC or Sports Center in Poland is talking about Bo.
Bo is a bully to players, the media and even fans. Maybe in real life away from football he is a bully too. He would not survive in a real world job with this demeanor. No employer would allow his antics or attitude to remain as they are now. Why does he get away with it here in the football world? Because it is football. All his loyal fans, even if they don’t care about how he acts, depend on his decisions and “leadership” to win games.
My question is whether Bo realizes the error of his ways when he completely overshadows the players when they accomplish great things. Rather than tout the biggest comeback in school history, he bashes the media.
Why not be above that and (even if it is difficult for Bo) sidestep questions about Martinez’s attitude while being scrutinized after playing Wisconsin? Why not instead,talk up the great things which all the players did to overcome their deficit to win a game? This would show pride in their accomplishments.
Players should look up to a coach for more than just football. They should be looking to him for leadership and inspiration about how to treat others with respect. Compare Pelini to Osborne or Devaney and tell me whether or not you consider Pelini a role model for compassion, respect and commitment to the public or individuals. A role model should stick to the same values 24/7 whether the cameras are catching it or not.
Bo Pelini does not seem to care about how he gets results unless his questionable actions are caught on tape.
Being protective of his players and the program is fine, expected even. The media will most times, run with the most compelling aspect of some sound byte or video. At the press conference, the most compelling aspect of the Ohio win SHOULD have been Bo’s pride with the biggest comeback in UNL history, not that Bo is still mad at some news article and the Nebraska Nation voiced being a bit disgruntled during the previous week.
At the post-game press conference following the Ohio game, Taylor Martinez, likely following the example set by his coach, took a similar tact. Rather then beam with pride about a well played game, he got defensive about how the media had talked about him.
What is Bo trying to get from his players? If it is just to win the game, then he missed the mark. There is much more to leading a team then just winning. Winning is great for the school and the fans. Most certainly, it is the spirit of teamwork, respect, commitment to learn and perfect technique, with pride in work effort and ethics that should be ancillary values but very important to learn. it seems these things are gone from Pelini’s coaching curriculum.
Like it or not, Bo Pelini will have to deal with the media and fans. They will love the team and players when they win. They will grumble when they loose. That’s life.
The media, like it or not, has to walk on eggshells when writing about Bo Pelini lest they be castigated and not allowed to practices, access to interview players or press conferences…. something which would lessen that media’s viewership and the bottom line, the dollar. Fans would be pretty upset too if they could not learn about their beloved Huskers.
Respect is a two way street. When Bo arrived back in Lincoln, he was given red carpet treatment (no pun intended) and the media was all about promoting him. His voiced disdain and even loathing of the media has put him in an awkward position. Bo has refused to allow access by the media already during his tenure.
By not working WITH the reporters, it seems the reporters have to work behind the scenes to get information, which upsets Bo too. It is a double edged sword and Bo needs to decide what he needs to do and which is the lesser evil.
I really wonder who has seen recent video of Bo going off, face to face with someone in the media, when the press conference was over and he thought all cameras were off. Husker Mike completely failed to mention this, even though he had a front row seat to the event. What would the Husker Nation think of Bo then?
If this leaked out to the general public, I really wonder if Osborne would be having a lengthy counseling moment with Bo, or be handing him a pink slip… it was THAT bad.





























