Corn Nation: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
Around SBN: Sean Keeley's Week 12 College Football Buffet

Nebraska's Offensive Problems Run Deep

Cody Green might be the most talented quarterback to come to Nebraska in over ten years. (AP Photo/Waco Tribune Herald,Jerry Larson)

More photos » by Jerry Larson - AP

Cody Green might be the most talented quarterback to come to Nebraska in over ten years. (AP Photo/Waco Tribune Herald,Jerry Larson)

Nebraska offensive coordinator Shawn Watson has been fielding a lot of criticism in recent weeks over the play of the Huskers.  And while the last few weeks haven't been Watson's finest, I don't think Watson the offensive coordinator deserves much of the blame.  Looking over the problems Nebraska is facing, I think Watson's previous role as recruiting coordinator might actually deserve more of the blame.  The Husker offense is suffering from a dearth of playmakers, and that's the result of injuries and, believe it or not, poor recruiting.

Steven M. Sipple of the Lincoln Journal-Star raised my eyebrows this afternoon in a radio interview with Kevin Kugler on KOZN radio (1620 AM in Omaha) when he said that he thought "Baylor had better players on offense, even without Robert Griffin."  Stop and think about that statement, and let that sink in.

Baylor has more offensive talent than Nebraska?

The first response to that is disbelief, but after you think about it, it's hard to argue with that statement.  Granted, injuries to Roy Helu, Rex Burkhead, and finally Dontrayevous Robinson really limited Nebraska offensively in Waco.  When you factor in the dismissal of Quentin Castille, nearly every football team in the country would suffer greatly if they lost their top four running backs.

My primary concern is the lack of production at wide receiver.  Nebraska started redshirt freshman Khiry Cooper, sophomore junior college transfer Brandon Kinnie, and junior Niles Paul at wide receiver on Saturday.  None of those players even appeared in the last spring game (Paul was suspended, Kinnie was still in junior college, and Cooper was playing baseball).  That's a whole lot of inexperience out there, and the direct results of recruiting problems.

That's right.  Bill Callahan, the coach who was supposed to solve Nebraska's so-called "recruiting problem" might actually have created one instead.  Look at his track record after he arrived at Nebraska in finding receivers.  Other than Maurice Purify, just who did Callahan attract to Nebraska?  Niles Paul is the nephew of Ahman Green, so he likely was going to come to Nebraska regardless.  Terrence Nunn and Nate Swift committed to Nebraska prior to Callahan's arrival.  Todd Peterson was a walk-on from Grand Island; he probably was coming to Nebraska anyway. Frantz Hardy might be the best name on the list.

With Swift and Peterson gone, Nebraska's offense has struggled and finally bypassed the depth chart to insert Kinnie and Cooper.  Inexperienced, yes.  But they aren't making the mistakes the older veterans made either.

It's not just wide receiver that's the problem, but receiver is where the problem is most glaring at this time.  There are offensive line problems, to be sure, and substitutions aren't in the cards at this time there.  This one may take time to unwind:  college football doesn't have a waiver wire that allows you to immediately rebuild and start over.  The process takes time and effort.

There's a huge difference between recruiting and recruiting ratings.  The evaluation of recruiting is an inexact science at best, and the ratings are wrong almost as often, if not more so, than they are right.  That doesn't make recruiting overrated, just the evaluation.  Only time allows you to evaluate recruiting.

And right now, time is not reflecting well on Bill Callahan's work at Nebraska.

1 recs  |  Comment 8 comments  |  Add comment |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Love the new design!

Much, much better looking.

by Mr. Bump on Nov 3, 2009 11:24 AM CST reply actions   0 recs

Mike-

You have to include the defensive players that BC recruited though. And his past RB’s have been fairly talented.

I would expect the coaches to bust their ass going out and recruiting some WR and RB’s to fill these voids as well.

You can't possibly be a scientist if you mind people thinking that you're a fool.
~Wanko the Sane
Big Red Kool-aid Drinker @ Corn Nation

by JLew on Nov 3, 2009 1:21 PM CST reply actions   0 recs

Even that's a mixed bag...

Ndamukong Suh is obviously the prize of that fabled 2005 class, but the list of misses in that class is large. And in the secondary, we’re watching Pelini recruits like Dejon Gomes and Alfonzo Dennard push their way into the lineup.

by Husker Mike on Nov 3, 2009 9:57 PM CST up reply actions   0 recs

This comment is incredibly disingenuous...

…and in no way addresses JLew’s prior statement on the current makeup of the NU defense.

For starters, anyone who gives a hoot about what Steve Sipple thinks really needs to step back and let that sink in…but that’s a conversation for another day.

I can’t believe we’re still even having this same tired conversation (hasn’t Callahan been coaching the Jets for two seasons now?!) But let me spell it out for everyone (so as not to be confused by the insane intimation that Suh is the only Callahan recruit of note on the current incarnation of the blackshirts):

Suh, Crick, Allen, Turner, Dillard, Asante, O’Hanlon, Hagg, Amukamara=Callahan recruits

Compton, Fisher, Gomes, Dennard=Pelini recruits

So yeah, that guy had no eye for talent…whatever, Mike. I realize that this all runs contrary to the axe you’ve ground down to a nub for several years now…but still, when 70% of the current starting defensive lineup was recruited by that bastard Callahan, well, let’s just say it sort of puts a huge dent into the theory you’re peddling here. That’s not even broaching the issue of your selective reasoning as to how four separate receivers (who each signed their letters of intent and sent them into Bill Callahan) now somehow don’t count as “Callahan recruits”. By your logic, I guess Sean Fisher needs moved to the Callahan ledger…since he committed in June of 2007—and being from Millard North, he was “probably coming to Nebraska anyway.” (I wonder if the fact that his dad was an NU letterwinner in the early 80’s technically makes him a TO recruit? But I digress.)

But I will wholeheartedly second meatybob’s thoughts here, on how talent development was among Callahan’s greatest weaknesses. But after two springs and a regular season and a half, I just have to ask when will the time come for us to comfortably examine Bo’s own ability to nurture talent (especially that of the side of the ball which lines up opposite to his own personal area of expertise)? In that regard, he seems to be currently suffering from his own divergent form of “Callahan syndrome”.

In reading this entire missive…it just seems incredibly weird to know that two years later, there are still people out there who willingly prop up the lame notion that there is no fault or blame to lay at the feet of the current coach/staff/players as long as we still have the Callahan regime to blame for whatever our current woes may be. (Oh, I stand corrected: at least we still have Shawn Watson to kick around.) It’s all quite reminiscent of the laughable examples of groupthink (primarily some now all-but-defunct message boards which shall not be named) that continued to berate Frank Solich & crew for several years into the Callahan experience. (So I guess in that light, it may be weird…but not “incredibly” so.)

But that actually really scares me to death…I want Bo and his staff to succeed so badly (as I did Callahan’s) but excusing current shortcomings as the fault of their predecessor is like a bad form of deja vu. I can only take solace in the fact that Bo seems to portray himself as being a lot more personally accountable for the entire team’s performance than Callahan ever did…so I can only hope that this situation will correct itself in time. Surely Bo would not fault current failures on the actions/decisions of the coach who preceded him…so why are so many Husker fans so eager to do so?! Take Bo at his word when he claims that “the buck stops here” or whatever. I don’t get how that can possibly be interpreted as an invitation to fire off 1,000+ words on one’s ruminations as to how “time has not reflected well on Bill Callahan’s work at Nebraska”. Yeah…the ship has sailed on that one. The time that did not reflect well on Bill Callahan’s work at Nebraska took place in 2007 and it is now part of the quickly fading past…so let’s just do ourselves a favor and leave it at that.

However, Mike’s sentiments really beg the question…if we light up OU this weekend (or do anything, for that matter, that can be perceived as “good” this season) I guess doing so would be primarily a result of the crappy players who you’d have us believe that Callahan supposedly wiffed on during his recruiting cycles!? In that way, I guess you just can’t have it both ways Husker Mike…you’d better hope we get drilled by the sooners, as it seems the only way you’ll be able to continue to clamor on with such nonsense concerning circumstances of days gone by.

by DTsker on Nov 4, 2009 11:46 PM CST up reply actions   0 recs

You make valid points about development...

…but sometimes, you can only do so much with some people. Here’s the question I have: How is it that guys like Khiry Cooper (who missed spring practice playing baseball) and Brandon Kinnie (juco transfer) have been able to jump into the lineup and bypass guys who’ve been in the program for years. Obviously Cooper and Kinnie have been able to be developed quickly.

Yes, I’m focusing exclusviely at the wide receiver position here. I see your points about the defense, and they are good observations. But how do you explain the wide receiver problems in 2009? How the heck could this program run a West Coast Offense without any receivers?

by Husker Mike on Nov 15, 2009 5:19 PM CST up reply actions   0 recs

Don't forget about development...

If anything, i think that was Callahan biggest weakness. Take a guy like Lucky, tons of talent, never really developed into anything more that what he was out the HS. To be frank, its not like Tech and Missou and KU outrecruited us, but over the last 4 years have gotten more out of their players.

Also, when Callahan was canned, we lost some obvious talent from that 08 class. Right now, Gabbert seems far better than any of our current options at QB.

by meatybob on Nov 3, 2009 3:29 PM CST reply actions   0 recs

Measurables vs. Intangibles

With this O-Line being all Callahan players, Watson and Cotton are probably going to have to recruit their way out of this. It seems like Billy C did the typical NFL thing and got caught up in a lineman’s “measurables” (height, arm span, etc.) rather than intangible qualities. I think what’s needed is a more Milt Tenopir-type formula for recruiting O-Linemen. He always said he wanted big guys who can run and have that “fire in the belly.”

by Section 37 on Nov 3, 2009 7:13 PM CST reply actions   0 recs

i believe

that Ricky Henry is a Cotton recruit….. if he can get his head on straight, he may be damned good.

Go Big Red Nebraska!
Our Cobs Are Bigger Than Yours!
Corn Nation!
Twitter!
cornnation@gmail.com

by corn blight on Nov 3, 2009 10:07 PM CST up reply actions   0 recs


User Tools

CN needs your tips! Inform us with an email to: cornnation - at - gmail.com. Better yet, join the CN community and create a fanpost or fanshot!
Follow Us On Twitter
Start posting about the Cornhuskers »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Dsc01361_small
Ask a K-State Blogger
Small
This article has nothing to do with the Huskers
Small
Some videos from Lincoln and Lawrence.
Img_4126_small
Week 11 Observations
Dsc01361_small
Nebraska Commit Andrew Rodriguez Chosen for Army All-America Bowl
Small
Tailgating in Waco
Texas_20tech_20logo_small
RedRaider fan of Husker Fans!
S1160561412_30041162_2216_small
Blackshirt tradition never dies
Clonechronicles_small
Ask A Cyclone
Small
Conspiracy?

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Highlights

FanShots

Quick hits of video, photos, quotes, chats, links and lists that you find around the web.

Recommended FanShots

In The Deed The Glory - Nebraska Tunnel Walk Vs. OU 2009. Shown last night before the game. No wonder the crowd was amped.

Recent FanShots

Nebraska's Recent Top 5 Picks
Over 100 pass attempts over the last 2 games
Nebrasketball Importable Calendar
Beaten up, bloodied, but the Huskers BEAT OU!!!
They May Take Our Lives...
While today's game is proof that Nebraska isn't and never was "back"...the reaction of the Cyclones indicates that beating Nebraska is still something special.  (HT: Clone Chronicles)
Packers bring back Ahman Green
The Case Against Awards - Or, Don't Worry If Suh Doesn't Win
Curtis Carter, WR, Stonewall, LA
Yep...another highlight reel from the Nebraska-Missouri game.  Never get tired of watching this, right?

+ New FanShot All FanShots >


Managers

Photo_6_small corn blight

Rc_icon_small Husker Mike

Editors

Hobbes2_small JLew

Authors

Josh2005_small huskerlibrarian

Cornguy_small Cobby

Official Partner of CBS Sports