Corn Nation: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
Around SBN: Holy War Week Brings out the Worst in Fans

NCAA Should Keep Text Messaging Ban

On August 9th the NCAA will reconsider it's ban on the use of text messaging as a recruiting communication tool. The issue will be re-examined due to an 'override'  in which more than 30 NCAA members requested a review of the issue. I've spent the last 20 years working in network and communication technology so this is subject is near and dear to me. When it comes to ubiquitous communication technology, there is always a fine line between being in constant contact and being interrupted by some beeping or buzzing device.

Most people probably take the view on text messaging similar to that recently displayed by Terry Bowden.

I didn't own a cell phone 25 years ago, but we wouldn't think of banning their use. I had never been on the Internet 15 years ago, but we couldn't live without it today in the recruiting process. Banning text messaging was a knee-jerk reaction to a "not so new" technology, and we need to go back and treat it like we have everything else and merely add some reasonable limitations to its use. ...

Unfortunately this view is simplistic and doesn't take into account several factors as to why text messaging was banned in the first place. As reported by Josh Centor from the NCAA, "student athletes reported that the recruiting practice adversely affected their lives".  Evidence of such can be found in an interview with a recruit named Jeff Hawkins who complained that it "gets annoying" and about generic messages being sent out at 1:00 or 2:00 am.

Add to these complaints a study from RIM, the manufacturer of the ubiquitous corporate Blackberry mobile communicator, that states that the Blackberry is great for productivity, but bad for 'life balance' and you get the idea that coaches are more worried about their own jobs without giving a damn as to how it affects their recruits. Recruits are already bombarded by interviews and emails from fan recruiting sites like Rivals.com and Scout.com (for which there are no NCAA limits), do we need to add generic text messaging on top of that?

Maryland coach Ralph Friegden complains there's no way to govern if another coaching is texting when they shouldn't be, but there's also no way to tell if a coach is texting outside of any proposed limits either. A complete ban would be easier to govern than any proposed compromise. Recruits can more easily report any coach who feels an obsessive need for constant communication.

Employers who use such technologies can reward their employees by giving them a good review, a raise, an advancement, providing more training by which they may further their careers, -  a myriad of rewards can be provided. Between the coach and the recruit the only award available is a scholarship and if the recruit is wanted that badly, he'll get one anyway.

The ban isn't about the NCAA being ignorant of the technology. Texting is not as simplistic as being 'one more form of communication'. The ban should stay in place out of respect for the prospective student-athletes who have enough happening in their young lives without one more needless distraction.

0 recs  |  Comment 4 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Another Reason to Ban Texting

Text messages are different than most other types of communication in that both the sender AND the receiver get charged for the message.  While many cell phone plans have an allowance for text messages, a student may not be aware of the limits (since the parents are paying the bill) until after a huge bill has been run up. When this ban was enacted, there were cases where players had to pay huge cell phone bills because of the number of text messages they were receiving from coaches.

by Husker Mike on Aug 7, 2007 10:32 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

what are the rules..

concerning phone or email contact?  Those are restricted in some way, right?  Why couldn't text messaging be regulated in a similar way?

Can you hear this, Denver, or shall I turn it up for you?

by Ignignokt on Aug 8, 2007 3:19 AM CDT reply actions   0 recs

I believe that there are phone limits...
...but not on e-mail.  The main reason why the text message ban was instituted was complaints from students because of the impact of time and money.  But none of the schools that proposed alternatives came up with a suggestion that allieviates those concerns.  So the ban stays.

by Husker Mike on Aug 10, 2007 10:18 AM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

I'm all for that.

Recruiting is insane. At some point they're going to have to regulate how early these guys are going after kids.

Go Big Red!

by Jon Johnston on Aug 12, 2007 9:29 AM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

CN needs your tips! Inform us with an email to: cornnation - at - gmail.com. Better yet, join the CN community and create a fanpost or fanshot!
Follow Us On Twitter
Start posting about the Cornhuskers »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Dsc01361_small
Ask a K-State Blogger
Small
This article has nothing to do with the Huskers
Small
Some videos from Lincoln and Lawrence.
Img_4126_small
Week 11 Observations
Dsc01361_small
Nebraska Commit Andrew Rodriguez Chosen for Army All-America Bowl
Small
Tailgating in Waco
Texas_20tech_20logo_small
RedRaider fan of Husker Fans!
S1160561412_30041162_2216_small
Blackshirt tradition never dies
Clonechronicles_small
Ask A Cyclone
Small
Conspiracy?

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Highlights

FanShots

Quick hits of video, photos, quotes, chats, links and lists that you find around the web.

Recent FanShots

Nebraska's Recent Top 5 Picks
Over 100 pass attempts over the last 2 games
Nebrasketball Importable Calendar
Beaten up, bloodied, but the Huskers BEAT OU!!!
They May Take Our Lives...
While today's game is proof that Nebraska isn't and never was "back"...the reaction of the Cyclones indicates that beating Nebraska is still something special.  (HT: Clone Chronicles)
Packers bring back Ahman Green
The Case Against Awards - Or, Don't Worry If Suh Doesn't Win
Curtis Carter, WR, Stonewall, LA
Yep...another highlight reel from the Nebraska-Missouri game.  Never get tired of watching this, right?

+ New FanShot All FanShots >


Managers

Photo_6_small Jon Johnston

Rc_icon_small Husker Mike

Editors

Hobbes2_small JLew

Authors

Josh2005_small huskerlibrarian

Cornguy_small Cobby

Official Partner of CBS Sports